روایت‌شناسی بلاغی رمان پنجشنبه فیروزه‌ای

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 عضو علمی گروه زبان و ادبیات فارسی دانشگاه پیام نور

2 عضو علمی گروه زبان و ادبیات فارسی دانشگاه پیا م نور

چکیده

«روایت‌شناسیِ بلاغی» یا «بلاغت داستان»، یکی از زیرشاخه‌های روایت‌شناسی پساکلاسیک در نظریة روایت معاصر با هدف کشف شگردهایی است که موجب تأثیر روایت بر مخاطب می‌گردد. این رویکرد، روایت را یک کنش ارتباطی هدفمند فرض می‌کند. در این نگاه، روایت صرفا بازنمایی رویداد‌ها نیست، بلکه خود نیز یک رویداد است؛ رویدادی که در آن نویسنده به دنبال جلب توجه و تأثیر بر شناخت، احساسات و ارزش‌های مخاطبان است. در این مقاله پس از بسط مفهوم بلاغت داستان بر اساس آراء «وین سی.بوت»، رمان پنج شنبه فیروزه‌ای اثر سارا عرفانی مورد بررسی و تحلیل قرار گرفته است. رمان مذکور را می‌توان در گروه رمان‌های دینی جای داد که با هدف تعالی خواننده بر مدار سبک زندگی دینی خلق شده‌ است، کشف ترفندهای بلاغی این رمان -که علاوه بر اقبال مخاطبان، موفق به کسب جوایزی نیز گردیده- می‌تواند ما را در تحلیل رمان‌های دینی معاصر یاری کند. در این مقاله، رمان در سه سطح «نویسنده»، «متن»، «خواننده» با هدف یافتن ترفندهای بلاغی موجد تأثیر بر مخاطب، بازخوانی و تحلیل شده‌ است. نتیجه این‌که «نویسنده» آگاهانه کوشیده‌است ترفندهایی را برای رسیدن به سطح بلاغی مطلوبش به‌کار‌گیرد (ترفند تقابل، حقیقت‌نمایی، تغییر زاویه دید و راوی، استدلال و ترفند توجیه آن، انتخاب موضوع خاص) و به وسیله آن به هدف اصلی داستان (ارتباط با مخاطب، رشد فکری-معنوی انسان به مدد قوه انتخاب‌گری) برسد. در «متن» نیز حضور نشانه‌ها و تنش‌های گفتمانی می‌تواند در مسیر این تاثیرگذاری باشد. سطوح مختلف مخاطب یعنی «خواننده» و شیوه تأثیرگذاری داستان بر آن‌ها نیز مورد توجه قرار گرفته است.

کلیدواژه‌ها

عنوان مقاله [English]

Rhetorical narrative of the novel panjshanbe firuzeei

نویسندگان [English]

  • fateme shekardast 1
  • narges mohamadi-badr 2

1 Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Payame Noor University

2 Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Payame Noor University

چکیده [English]

Rhetoric narratology is one of sub-categories of post-classic narratology in the contemporary narrative theory. Actually, the rhetoric narratology is looking forward to influencing plot on the audience and discovering rhetoric structures.
In rhetorical approach, narration is assumed as a targeted communicative action. In this view, narration is not merely a representation of events. It is an event in which speakers seek to attract attention and influence the audience’s values. In rhetoric narratology, an implied author is paid more attention rather than a narrator. The implied author is an applied semantic identity that belongs more to interpretive rhetoric than narrative rhetoric.
In this article, after expanding this term based on the theory of Mikhail Bakhtin (as the initiator of this theory) and Wayne C. Booths, the novel of Turquoise Thursday by Sara Erfani has been read and interpreted in three levels of author, text and reader. Therefore, the implied author and his/her tricks in rhetoric functions of the story (contrast trick, realization, changing the point of view and narrator, argument and its justification trick, intelligent choice of the plot) are considered. Discourse stresses and signs and finally different levels of audience and influential ways are considered in the text. As a result, the author has tried to use some tricks in order to reach her favorite rhetoric level and the main aim of the story (intellectual and spiritual growth of the human being through electoral capability). This effort is as a separate event that constitutes rhetoric structure of the story.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • rhetoric narratology
  • navel
  • religious novel
  • turquoise Thursday novel
  • Sara Erfani

Narratology is a field that has been considered in various forms since the beginning of the twentieth century and many people like Propp, Schlofsky, Baret and others have addressed it in their theories. Rhetorical narratology is a type of narrative reading of the text and analysis of the novel. The combination of contemporary narratology and rhetoric creates rhetorical narratology or story rhetoric, which is a one of the sub-categories of post- classical narratology in the contemporary narrative theory, and seeks to discover tricks that affect the narrative on the audience. This approach assumes narrative as a targeted communication action. In this view, narration is not merely a representation of events, but an event in itself, an event in which the author seek to attract  attention and influence the cognition, feelings and values of the audience.

In addition to story rhetoric, pragmatics and discourse analysis- two new branches of linguistics- have also paved the way for new critique with the help of rhetoric; with the difference that traditional semantics is narrative –oriented, while these two new branches of linguistics- which can be called new semantics- are also readers-oriented, that is, it pay attention to both the speaker and the reader. Bakhtin believes that fiction is a subset of rhetoric, because what is does is goal-oriented. Bakhtin argues that the novel has more in common with poetry at any given historical point in time than with the rhetorical forms, such as languages used in journalism, ethics, religion, politics and economics.

Attention to structural narratology in recent years in Iran has led to less attention to rhetorical narratology and rhetorical research. In books such as the Encyclopedia of Narrative (in an article by David Herman) translated by Mohammad Ragheb (2012) and some other books of linguistics, novels and text books have been made brief references to this theory (the rhetoric of the story). But the practical critique of the story based on this theory is limited to Mohammad Ragheb's article entitled "analysis of the short story Tree by Goli Taraghi from the perspective of rhetorical narratology (2015)" which by clearly distinguishing between structural narratology and rhetorical narratology, he has scientifically studied three generations of rhetorical theorists, and analyzed the story based on it; About the novel of Turquoise Thursday, as one of the most popular religious-social novels in recent years, no scientific research has been so far, however, due to the audience, there are specialized criticisms in the form of meetings, lectures and interviews.

In this article, after expanding the concept of story rhetoric based on opinion (Wayne. C. Booths), the novel of Turquoise Thursday by Sara Erfani has been studied and analysis. This novel can be included in the group of religious novels that have been created with the aim of the reader's excellence in the orbit of religious lifestyle. Discovering the rhetorical tricks of this novel can help us in analyzing contemporary religious novels.

In this article, the novel has been reread and analyzed at three levels of author, text and reader with the aim of finding rhetorical tricks affecting the audience That the result of the research show that the author consciously tried to use tricks to reach the desired level of rhetoric and thereby reach the aim goal of the story, namely communication with the audience and human intellectual-spiritual development with the help of selectivity. The main theme of the story is the faithful lifestyle in the face of various matters such as love, marriage, pilgrimage, etc. and considering purposefulness and commitment of the religious story, it is natural for the author to seek the intellectual- spiritual development and moral excellence of the reader under the pretext of each, and to achieve this goal, use several rhetorical tricks. If we examine these tricks in the three areas of author, text and audience, in the first area, the implied author has subconsciously drown the reader into the area of judgment and selectivity with tricks such as the constant and uninterrupted confrontation between welfare and evil, light and darkness, right and wrong, normal and abnormal, love and lust, ascension and fall and …  in all scenes of the story, and has strengthened the effects on the reader with other tricks such as special choice of subject(love), truth-likeness, reasoning and its justification.

By examining the semiotics and discourse tension in the text- which indicates the upward trend of intensity and extensive in the schema- we come across factors that have contributed to the rhetoric of the story and the goals of the narrative; such as naming and anonymity and signs such as turquoise, philosophy, wounds, etc., the empathetic-emotional impact (intensity) by using the power of reason and reasoning of the audience (extensive) and the quantitative and qualitative fit of these two, creates a successful discourse tension in the story. An examination of the audience and recipients of the message which emphasis on it, is the most important distinction between traditional and modern rhetoric, shows that the author has tried to attract the attention of the narrative audience, the story audience and the ideal audience at the same time.               

Keywords: rhetoric narratology, novel, Religious novel, turquoise Thursday, Sara Erfani

فهرست منابع و ماخذ
   کتاب‌ها
- برتنز، یوهانس ویلم. (1388). نظریة ادبی؛ ترجمه فرزان سجودی، تهران: آهنگی دیگر.
- پاینده، حسین. (1394). گشودن رمان؛ چاپ سوم، تهران: مروارید.
- شمیسا، سیروس. (1386). معانی (ویرایش دوم)؛ چاپ اول، تهران: میترا.
- عرفانی، سارا. (1393). پنجشنبة فیروزه­ای؛ تهران: نیستان.
- فاولر، راجر. (1390). زبان­شناسی و رمان؛ ترجمۀ محمد غفاری، چاپ اول، تهران: نی.
- کلینگز، مری. (1388). درسنامة نظریة ادبی؛ ترجمۀ جلال سخنور، الهه دهنوی و سعید سبزیان، چ اول، تهران: اختران.
- میرصادقی، جمال. (1388). عناصر داستان؛ چاپ ششم، تهران: علمی.
- مقاله­ها
- اسماعیلی، عصمت، حمیدرضا شعیری و ابراهیم کنعانی. (1391). «رویکرد نشانه­معناشناختی فرآیند مربع معنایی با مربع تنشی»؛ پژوهش­های ادب عرفانی (گوهر گویا)، سال ششم، شمارة سوم، صص 69-94.
- راغب، محمد. (1393). «تحلیل داستان کوتاه درخت اثر گلی ترقی از دیدگاه روایت­شناسی بلاغی»؛ مجلة ادب فارسی، سال 4، شمارة 1، صص 113-132.
- شعیری، حمیدرضا. (1384). «مطالعة فرآیند تنشی گفتمان ادبی»؛ پژوهش ادبیات معاصر جهان، شمارۀ 25، صص 187 – 204.
------------- (1393). «مبانی نظری تحلیل گفتمان رویکرد نشانه ـ معناشناختی»؛ پژوهش­نامة فرهنگستان هنر، شمارة 12، صص 54-72.
- فیلان، جیمز. (1392). «بلاغت/ اخلاق»؛ ترجمة محمد راغب، کتاب ماه ادبیات، شمارة 73، پیاپی 187، صص 10 – 16.
دوره 1، شماره 1 - شماره پیاپی 1
دوفصلنامه ( شماره بهار و تابستان 1401)
فروردین 1401
صفحه 213-236
  • تاریخ دریافت: 27 دی 1399
  • تاریخ بازنگری: 20 مهر 1400
  • تاریخ پذیرش: 22 مهر 1400